Welcome to NewlyOpened! We help you discover new restaurants in Markham. Don't forget to bookmark NewlyOpened to stay updated on new openings!

See all new restaurants in Markham.
Osteria Mattarello
Loading photos...

Osteria Mattarello

Italian restaurant
4.1(170 reviews)
Open
Today's hours: 12 - 3 PM, 5 - 10 PM

Osteria Mattarello is a new restaurant in Markham opened more than 6 months ago.

Mattarello is a sophisticated, innovative Italian style restaurant located in the heart of Markham. Whether you are celebrating a new chapter in your life, a romantic occasion or just looking for a more intimate setting, Mattarello is here to ensure you have the most lavish experience possible. Pair our authentic Italian wines with our signature pastas to create a long lasting love for Italian cuisine. Finish off your evening with our delicious dessert and imported fresh coffee. We will ensure you are always leaving satisfied with a smile on your face.

Loading photos...

Location

230 Commerce Valley Dr E #2a, Thornhill, ON L3T 7Y3



Features

Service options

DeliveryTakeoutDine-in

Accessibility

Wheelchair accessible seatingWheelchair-accessible entranceWheelchair-accessible parking lotWheelchair-accessible washroom

Frequently mentioned about

calamarimushroom trufflegrilleddecortruffle pastapepperonitruffle frieshoneypistachio tiramisuprice point

Featured User Reviews

Enjoyed our meal at Mattrello! Friendly service and tasty food. The kale salad was a pleasant surprise and the bolognese tagliatelle was flavorful. Handmade pasta was a nice touch.

November 25, 2024 on Google

We recently hosted our company event at Mattarello, and everything was absolutely amazing! From the moment we arrived, the staff made us feel welcomed and attended to every detail with remarkable precision. The food was not only delicious but also served right on time. Each dish was flavorful and exceeded our expectations—our team is still talking about how tasty everything was! The menu offered a great variety, satisfying all palates. Service was impeccable and, dare I say, almost too attentive—in the best way possible! Our water glasses were never empty, and the staff constantly checked in to offer drinks or assist with anything we needed. Their professionalism and friendliness added a special touch to our event. I noticed some reviews mentioning service issues, but our experience was nothing short of outstanding. If you're considering a venue for a special occasion or just a fantastic dining experience, I highly recommend Mattarello. We look forward to returning soon!

November 17, 2024 on Google

First visit to this restaurant and I'm impressed with the food and friendly service. Ryan, our server made good recommendations and we were pleased with all the dishes. Looking forward to returning and try out the rest of their menu.

October 12, 2024 on Google

Had a great round of apps, mains, desserts and the most exceptional cocktails crafted by Mert! He was so innovative with his creations and I loved his pairings especially the one pictured (now named Mindy’s chocolate tears).

September 30, 2024 on Google

I visited this restaurant recently and was left quite underwhelmed. While the server/ hostess was very friendly, and the interior was cute, modern, and clean, the food did not impress. The menu is quite limited with a heavy emphasis on seafood and mushrooms, which might not cater to all tastes. The honey pepperoni pizza was disappointing, lacking in flavor and coming across as bland—almost like a frozen pizza. The cheese was stringy and the pepperoni plentiful, but the overall taste was forgettable. The pasta dish was even more problematic. It arrived swimming in grease, with the noodles practically drenched in oil. The portion size for the $30 price point was frustratingly small, served in a bowl that seemed more appropriate for a child’s meal. The pasta was supposed to be cooked in a red wine reduction, but that flavor was entirely missing. Additionally, the cheese was not freshly grated, instead coming in a tiny bowl and extremely finely grated. Overall, the food missed the mark on flavor and quality, making it a disappointing experience despite the nice setting and friendly service. I would not come back again.

August 17, 2024 on Google

The mushroom truffle pasta is delicious. One of the better pastas we have had. Pizza flavoring is nice with a sweet honey sauce. The fruiti de mare appetizer was crispy with a light breading. Would definitely return.

August 4, 2024 on Google

FOOD POISONING! DO NOT RECOMMEND. Celebrated girlfriend’s birthday and got a food poisoning! Went to this restaurant for a Saturday dinner. There was no other customers for the entire night! We ordered a pizza, fish, and a pasta. Fish was cold in the centre and ended up got food poisoning for entire week. Expensive and not worth! Prices are quite high and they used dried pastas instead of fresh with this price.

June 3, 2024 on Google

First time trying this restaurant, mix feelings.. The decor is quite clean and comfortable and the service is quite friendly. The appetizer kale salad and the tomato salad are worth the asking price in terms of portion, plating, and taste! I particularly like the tomato salad with the hint of truffle flavor mushroom. Unfortunately, the main dish we tried is underwhelming. We tried the fish and for a dish over $40, the dish lacks special flavour. The fish is indeed well pan fried with crunchy skin but under seasoned. And is place on top of a bowl of spinach cream sauce (which also bland) which make it hard to eat without soaking the nice crunchy fish skin wet. The dish seems served on a soup bowl therefore isn’t room for any other sides. It’s a small dish in my opinion for the asking price. I gotta say, Fishbone restaurant has better fish dish with cheaper price also.

October 30, 2023 on Google